Undone: a Review by Laura Black
Undone is the fourth book in the Undone college hockey series set at Waterfell University. Main characters Toren Kane and Lily LaBlanc are in their early twenties and as with the previous books, the tension is all about their backstory. This is a second chance for Toren and Lily who had a deep childhood friendship before they were driven apart by Lily’s overprotective father.
All these books are intense, and this one especially so. Toren’s background is tragic, as he was bounced around foster homes, only finding value when he is with Lily, and as a hockey enforcer. Lily is smothered by her father and the relationship is complicated – he is her only parent, and she is suffering from depression, craving love and attention and trying to live her own life. What is essentially coercive control by her father is thoughtfully depicted and Lily seems so childlike at times, perhaps because of that overprotection, but she is not stupid.
Lily and Toren reconnect when Lily’s father takes an assistant coaching job at Waterfell and Lily comes along. Very quickly Toren is looking out for her and up in her business, while her father is taunting and manipulating Toren at hockey practice. There’s a tacit acknowledgement in the text that the connection between Toren and Lily is codependent and a bit obsessive – the reader must believe that it works and they can grow together – after all, Lily is only twenty two and they are talking about ‘forever’. My reservations are that the book feels long, with too much time spent on Toren’s interactions with Lily’s father. It does seem as if the only happy times are when Toren and Lily are having sex – I’d have loved more light among all the darkness of their situation.
That said, Peyton Corrine has written an immersive and angsty second-chance romance and I loved the connection between Toren and Lily. My favourite in this series is Unloved, with Freddy and Ro, so it was great to see cameos of them, as well as secondary characters Paloma (from Unbound) who becomes a flatmate and close friend to Lily, and Holden, who sticks up for Toren – and provides a some bi-complexity. Perhaps there will be a book for him?
Thank you so much Peyton Corinne and Hachette ANZ for the ARC. Opinions are my own.
Laura Black is a romance editor, reader and reviewer based in Queensland, Australia. You can visit me on Instagram @laura_black_reads

Leave a Reply