Pulling Out the Stops: A review by Caz
I’m a grouch who is usually resistant to anything Christmassy before the beginning of December, but books tend to be the one exception I make to that rule, hence my picking up Fearne Hill’s Pulling Out the Stops in early November! Fortunately, while the story is set around the Christmas period and features a church choir preparing for a Christmas Eve performance, it’s not overly Christmassy, if that makes sense; it’s winter, there is snow (more than one kind!), and there are carols, but I never felt as though I was being hit over the head with the seasonal theme, and that is exactly how I prefer my end-of-year romances!
So Fearne Hill had already scored big-time, and as I read, I realised that she could have actually written this book for me because one of the protagonists is a musician (me) and a music teacher (me) who has sung in/directed choirs (me), and I absolutely bought into his passion for music, for teaching (no matter that it’s an incredibly frustrating job a lot of the time!) and for coaching his choir of enthusiastic locals to sing their hearts out and put on the the best concert they possibly could.
This character is Felix Chesterton, a virtuoso organist and musical prodigy whose family of high-flying musicians (his brother is a principal cellist, his sister is a world-renowned harpist, his father is Director of Music at King’s College Cambridge, so they’re musical royalty) are constantly pushing him towards a high-pressure life of constant travel and high-profile engagements he doesn’t really want, and he’s burned out. To take a breather and to try to work out what he wants his life to look like, he’s taken a temporary teaching position at the primary school in his home town, and also became choirmaster at the local church. His family thinks it’s beneath him, especially as he’s been offered a very prestigious position at Canterbury Cathedral, but Felix feels, for probably the first time in his life, like he’s actually doing something he wants to do for himself, and that making music is fun again – something he realises he’s lost sight of over the years defined by constant practice and performance. Out from under that weight – albeit temporarily – Felix is more himself than he’s ever been; funny, snarky, radiating confidence and with an upbeat outlook that is utterly irresistible.
University lecturer Cameron Snow has just broken up (again) with his boyfriend of six years and is determined that this time it really IS the end; it’s not the first time Gryff has cheated, and even though Cam has let Gryff persuade him to take him back in the past, he is absolutely not going to cave this time. He just needs to be strong enough to resist Gryff’s attempts to get him back when they come. But knowing Gryff is a cheating, supercilious bastard who manipulated his emotions and turned him into someone else doesn’t mean the break-up doesn’t hurt, or that Cam isn’t grieving for the life he thought he’d had.
Cam is staying with his parents over the Christmas break, planning to wallow a bit, indulge in too much good food (and drink) and maybe start figuring out where he goes from here. But he should’ve known his parents wouldn’t let him do the first one for very long, and soon, his dad has dragged him out to choose Christmas trees, and his mum has roped him into singing with the church choir for the Christmas Eve service. At the first practice, he’s surprised to find that he recognises the bubbly, dorky choirmaster with the tousled reddish hair and the seemingly endless stream of musical double-entendres; Cam was friends with Charlie Chesterton in school, and he remembers his younger brother, Felix, would often trail around after them.
Cam and Felix are both thoroughly engaging, loveable guys who are at turning points in their lives and are struggling to come to terms with where they’re at and to work out who they are and what they want. Their chemistry is electric, even though they both try to fight it to start with – they know they’re not going to be sticking around, and getting involved, even just for a short time, is a bad idea. But even the worst ideas can sometimes turn out well, and despite their best efforts to be ‘just’ friends, they simply can’t resist the intensity of the attraction thrumming between them – so they agree to a no strings fling. As any romance reader worth their salt will know, no strings flings in this genre are doomed to fail because feelings are invariably caught – but what I adored about this story is that even once feelings are involved, the obstacles to their relationship – namely Cam’s ex and Felix’s career – remain, and being in love doesn’t magically fix them. What it does do, however, is give both men the support and the courage to make the decisions that are right for them – after years of doing what is expected of them or doing whatever will make someone else happy. Felix’s care, humour and attentiveness show Cam, day after day, that he’s strong enough to walk away from his manipulative ex and that he deserves so much better; and helping Cam to realise that helps Felix to see that he, too, can break the cycle of expectation, stand up to his overbearing relatives and do what’s best for him for a change.
Novellas can be hit and miss for me, but Pulling Out the Stops was an absolute delight from start to finish. In just under 170 pages, Fearne Hill has crafted a warm, funny and tender romance with depth and insight, great character and romantic development, and delivers a happy ending that works absolutely perfectly. Whenever you’re in the mood for some distinctly British festive cheer complete with silly Christmas jumper slogans, more musical innuendoes about organs and pipes than you can shake a stick at and a Dibley-esque cast of secondary characters who are more than just window-dressing, this one is guaranteed to bring a smile to your lips and warmth to your cockles. Highly recommended.
About Caz
I’m a musician, teacher and mother of two gorgeous young women who are without doubt, my finest achievement 🙂 I’ve gravitated away from my first love – historical romance – over the last few years and now read mostly m/m romances in a variety of sub-genres. I’ve found many fantastic new authors to enjoy courtesy of audiobooks – I probably listen to as many books as I read these days – mostly through glomming favourite narrators and following them into different genres.And when I find books I LOVE, I want to shout about them from the (metaphorical) rooftops to help other readers and listeners to discover them, too. www.bookish29.wordpress.com
2 responses to “Pulling Out the Stops: A review by Caz”
-
Thank you Caz, for sharing your review with us! I love Christmas music and novellas so this sounds really good.
-
I very much enjoyed your review, Caz, and am downloading a sample of the book. Thank you! I also spent way too much time browsing your site!

Leave a Reply