The Christmas Yes List: a Review by Lisa
Charming with a witty narrative voice that’s a total delight, The Christmas Yes List was an extremely amusing story with a great heroine. It’s a fine holiday romance that’s funny and charmingly awkward in a totally entertaining way.
Chloe Hollis is a chromic people-pleaser who has decided to collect ten “nos” before Christmas Day, after seeing a post from an influencer. Her plan is to ask strangers for favors, and keep score as she goes along.
Chloe has a good reason for doing this: she quit college at her boyfriend’s behest. More recently, she resigned from her job via email – where she hadn’t asked for a single promotion for six years, after her boss offered her a promotion in trade for her fudging his business misdeeds. She told him she’d do it, then ended up running away instead. She cruises for rejection from people on planes, trains and buses as she makes her way to her hometown.
Then she meets James Dutton, who asks her if she needs a lift. She turns him down, but anxiously offers to give HIM a ride. James himself is an uptight workaholic who isn’t good at relaxing, but Chloe starts worrying he read the same advice book that she has. A whole lot of charming banter sets in, and Chloe realizes she must try to get a no out of James, but despite her best effort, she cannot. Soon James challenges Chloe to join him on an adventure after they meet with their families for holiday get-togethers. But can Chloe accept James for who he is?
Man, did I love spending the holidays with Chloe. Yes, some readers may find it feels a little bit too much like a Hallmark movie, and Chloe may come across as too much. But for me that was a bonus. The Christmas Yes List has a personality and a sense of humor that’s top notch. The romance between our two mains is full of quirky and awkward moments, and it’s worth it. It’s made of purchased mannequins, fly fishing and fainting baby goats, and that appealed to me.
Chloe is one of those desperately awkward characters who makes you wonder if she can do anything without flailing and falling. But she grows throughout the book, learning to move past her anxieties and mix her yeses with nos. I related to her in an embarrassing way because I overthink everything all the time.
James mixes playfulness and seriousness with a sense of warmth I really enjoyed. His open affection for Chloe in spite of her worries was really touching.
Their romance was silly and adventuresome, but also had a real sense of growing closeness and I liked watching Chloe struggle against her most ridiculous instincts with him. She moves believably between dithering and being self-assured, a state I understood all too well.
The Christmasy feeling of the book definitely worked: trees, lights, tinsel and reindeer abounded. And I loved all the whole supporting flock – Genie, Chloe’s best friend, and her dad were big standouts for me.
I will say, though this novel was published by a faith-based-publisher, and all of the references the characters made to religion were minimal in the backgrounded perhaps because this will become a television movie soon. I liked The Christmas Yes List a whole lot. Maybe I’ve been made soft by the holiday season, but I thought this one was a real keeper.
Lisa Fernandes has been reviewing romance novels ever since her great aunt left a Billie Douglas book out in the bathroom. She’s currently working on a biography about Julian Sands.

Leave a Reply