Winter Magic at Hollybrae Castle: a Review by Lisa
Santa Claus is eating Paddington Bear! – the opening line, Winter Magic at Hollybrae Castle.
Look, if you start with a sentence like that, you’re going to win me over in a New York minute. Winter Magic at Hollybrae Castle does just that, and delivers a delightfully lighthearted holiday revelry with a proper sheen of romantic tomfoolery. It’s a fun, breezy, easy way to kick off the holiday season – all before people have finished taking down their Halloween decorations.
Lula Haines’ career comes crashing down when the holiday window display she created for a department store results in Paddington being eaten by Santa Claus thanks to an animatronic malfunction! The Calloway company immediately fires her and she’s sent home to her married sister’s house with no job to help pay the rent. Mira has kids and a whole life of her own, and Lula already feels guilty about taking advantage of her kindness.
A miracle arrives in the form of a help-wanted ad. A man needs someone to decorate his small Scottish castle. Lula’s portfolio lands her the job, and she’s soon jetting off to Scotland – even though her sister thinks Lula’s hubris is going to get her murdered.
The man who placed the ad is Oliver and the first thing he says to Lula doing a Zoom call is “will you marry me?” Lula almost runs for her life, but Oliver quickly explains he’s not some crazy creep looking for cheap sex. He needs her help because an accidental glitch has resulted in him inviting his boss and several colleagues to a holiday weekend fête.
Oliver is an investment accountant who’s looking for a promotion. He’s lied to his bosses, claiming he’s happily married, to fit the firm’s ethos and morals. Not only does he need a decorator, he also needs a fake wife and two kids to make his story believable. His housekeeper’s grandchildren, Maisy and Rory, are playing the kids, so all he needs is a wife. If he pulls this off, the promotion – and enough money to take care of upkeep and repairs on the castle – could be his. Lula needs the money too, and agrees to play the wife.
As the festivities unfold, Oliver and Lula easily slip into their roles as man and wife. Soon the promise of their relationship turning real begins to dawn – along with the risk that Oliver’s bosses will discover the truth and jeopardize both his career and Lula’s reputation.
This is a comedy of manners, with Lulu trying desperately to be posh and Oliver pretending to know what it’s like to be a dad. It’s also a beautiful slow-burn love story, about two awkward people who have long been put upon and manage to find love with one another. The romance is Christmassy and funny, but also tender, and thoughtful.
The holiday sheen has just the right level of coziness, and it keeps things light on the kiddie-sweet gloopiness – the children feel like real kids, holding slinky races and charging about in gleeful excitement. Everything is snowy and sweet. This is the kind of story where rivals become lovers and enemies. Nothing feels too cloying or ridiculous and everything feels perfectly cozy.
I really liked this little slice of early Christmas whimsy; Winter Magic at Hollybrae Castle is the right kind of lighthearted joy to send you into the holiday season.
Lisa Fernandes has been reviewing romance novels ever since her great aunt left a Billie Douglas book out in the bathroom. She’s currently working on a biography about Julian Sands.

Leave a Reply